Family: John C. NUTTER / Emily C. VINCENT (F3096) [1, 2]
-
Father | Male
John C. NUTTER
Born CA 1804 Died 10 Aug 1884 Ritchie Co, WV 
Buried (FIELDSTONE MARKER) Nutter Cemetery (Leatherbark Creek at Iris), Ritchie Co, WV Married Father John NUTTER | F3092 Group Sheet Mother Elizabeth COTTRELL | F3092 Group Sheet
Mother | Female
Emily C. VINCENT
Born CA 1812 Died Buried (UNMARKED) Nutter Cemetery (Leatherbark Creek at Iris), Ritchie Co, WV Father Mother
Child 2 | Female
Mary E. NUTTER
Born CA 1832 Doddridge Co, (W)VA Died 24 Apr 1908 Buried Mt. Zion Cemetery, Co Rd 50/2, Marietta Run, Ritchie Co, WV Spouse Henry M. SMITH | F6481 Married 24 Nov 1870 Ritchie Co, WV
Child 3 | Female
+ Cassa Ann NUTTER
Born 16 Mar 1833 Harrison Co, (W)VA Died Bef 1911 Buried Spouse Andrew Jackson ADAMS | F14230 Married 25 Sep 1853 Doddridge Co, (W)VA Spouse George H. MCQUAIN | F27153 Married 30 Jun 1881 West Union, Doddridge Co, WV
Child 4 | Female
+ Julia Ann NUTTER
Born 11 Jun 1835 Harrison Co, (W)VA Died Bef 1911 Buried Spouse Lewis ROGERS | F6480 Married 28 Aug 1856 Ritchie Co, (W)VA
Child 5 | Female
Darinda NUTTER
Born 4 Aug 1837 Died 1 May 1918 Buried Hardman Chapel Cemetery, Smithville, Ritchie Co, WV
Child 6 | Male
Andrew C. NUTTER
Born 24 Jun 1839 Died 6 Dec 1880 Buried Hardman Chapel Cemetery, Smithville, Ritchie Co, WV
Child 7 | Female
Ellen J. NUTTER
Born 11 Feb 1843 Died Buried Spouse William B. CONNOLLY | F6483 Married 9 Dec 1875
Child 8 | Male
+ John Nelson NUTTER
Born 26 Jul 1846 Ritchie Co, (W)VA Died 11 May 1912 Kingman, Kingman Co, KS Buried Walnut Hill Cemetery, Kingman, Kingman Co, KS Spouse Elizabeth Prince "Lizzie" DYE | F6482 Married 17 Sep 1867 Ritchie Co, WV
Child 9 | Male
+ Joseph Skelton NUTTER
Born 13 Sep 1847 Died Buried Spouse Charlotte ___ | F8646 Married
Child 10 | Male
+ William Thomas NUTTER
Born 13 Jul 1851 Virginia (now West Virginia) Died Buried Spouse Sarah Elizabeth WESTFALL | F8645 Married 8 Jan 1880 Ritchie Co, WV
Child 11 | Male
+ Avery Fillmore NUTTER
Born 28 Sep 1857 Died 4 Sep 1936 Parkersburg, Wood Co, WV Buried Ayers (aka Smithville) Cemetery, Smithville, Ritchie Co, WV Spouse Louisa Jane BARR | F8647 Married 31 Jan 1886 Ritchie Co, WV
-
Notes - We have found several discrepancies in the research done on this family:
(1) Jacob Nutter is listed by Minnie Kendall Lowther (HRC, p. 236) as one of the children of John C. Nutter & Emily Vincent, but not by Don Norman. We have found no other reference to this Jacob Nutter.
(2) Conversely, Don Norman lists Joseph Skelton Nutter and Avery Fillmore Nutter among their children, but Minnie Kendall Lowther does not. Joseph does appear twice as their son in census records, but Avery appears only once and is listed as a grandson. Avery's death record identifies his father as John Nutter, but does not name his mother.
(3) Lowther identifies one of John & Emily's children as Thomas Nutter, while Norman identifies him as William Thomas Nutter. This appears to be the same person.
1850 Census, Doddridge Co, Virginia (now West Virginia), enumerated on Jul 23 1850:
John C. Nutter, 39, farmer; Emily, 38; Mary, 18; Cassy, 16; Julia A, 15; Darinda, 13; Andrew, 10; Ellen J (or I), 7; John N, 5; Joseph S, 2; James Ross, 25.
1860 Census, Ritchie Co, Virginia (now West Virginia), enumerated in Aug 1860:
John C. Nutter, 54, farmer; Emily, 46; Mary E, 27; Darinda, 21; Andrew, 20 (noted as being insane, deaf & dumb); Ellen J, 16; John N, 14; Joseph S, 12; William T, 7.
1870 Census, Ritchie Co, WV (Murphy District), enumerated on Sep 9 1870:
John C. Nutter, 66, farmer; Emily C, 52; Mary, 30; Darinda, 23 (?); Andrew, 25; Ellen J, 21; Wm Thomas, 18.
(Note: The next household was that of Jacob M. & Eliza Smith and their children. One of their sons was Henry M. Smith, 22, who married Mary Nutter two months later.)
1880 Census, Ritchie Co, WV (Murphy District), enumerated on Jun 8 1880:
John C. Nutter, 75, farmer; wife Emily C, 69; son Andrew, 34, single; dau Derinda, 30, single; grandson Avery F, 21, single.
In the adjacent household: Wm T. Nutter, 24, farmer; wife Sarah, 22; farm worker Charles E. Rogers, 18, single. [3]
- We have found several discrepancies in the research done on this family:
-
Sources - [S770] The Descendants of Christopher Nutter (based on "The Nutter Family" by Barr Wilson), Donald E. Norman & Pauline Karabogias, (http://hackerscreek.com/norman/NUTTER/CHRISTOPHER1.htm).
- [S2722] Descendants of John Cottrell, Don Norman, 41991 Emerson Court, Elyria, OH 44035, (http://hackerscreek.com/norman/COTTRELL/JOHN.htm).
- [S293] History of Ritchie County, Minnie Kendall Lowther, (1911, reprinted 1999, McClain Printing Co, Parsons WV, http://McClainPrinting.com).
- [S770] The Descendants of Christopher Nutter (based on "The Nutter Family" by Barr Wilson), Donald E. Norman & Pauline Karabogias, (http://hackerscreek.com/norman/NUTTER/CHRISTOPHER1.htm).